NEWTEKWORLDNEWS
Menu

Orwellian renaming of surveillance strategies

15/3/2015

2 Comments

 
PictureEdward Snowden (Laura Poitras/ Praxis films)
Op-Ed: The former Bush administration, followed by media outlets, renamed practices such as water-boarding from being "torture" to "enhanced interrogation techniques".

The so-called Five Eyes group are now pushing a cooperative effort to  re-brand the "mass surveillance" they practice as "bulk collection", a much less menacing term that describes precisely the same surveillance. While mass surveillance is illegal, bulk collection of data is supposedly legal.

The Five Eyes(FVEY)_ consist of the US, UK, New Zealand, Australia, and Canada,| These countries carry out mass surveillance and share the information they collect  As part of the global War on Terror since 2001 the group has expanded their surveillance of the World Wide Web. Edward Snowden described the group as a "supra-national intelligence organisation that does not answer to the known laws of its own countries". Snowden's leaked documents show that FVEY spy on each other's citizens and then share the information to circumvent domestic laws on spying. For example Canada could spy on US citizens in a manner that is illegal for US spy agencies to do and then share the information with the US. Strictly speaking the US agencies did not do the spying on their own citizens. Some intelligence experts claim that the outrage caused by Snowden's revelations will not change the relationships or activities of the group that remains the most extensive espionage alliance in history so far.

A recent report whitewashes the activities of the British Government Communications Headquarter (GCHQ).

The report is from the "Intelligence and Security Committee of the UK Parliament "(ISC). The members of the oversight committee are appointed by the Prime Minister. It took for ages for the ISC to even consider some of the material in the Snowden leaks. As well as working the distinction between  "bulk collection" and "mass surveillance" the same old saw about just collecting meta-data was brought up. Actual conversations and content of messages are not collected. The head of M15 dismissed the idea of collecting data on the websites people visit as an intrusion on privacy. The type of legislation that the intelligence community would like to see is what might be called a Snooper's Charter, that would not legislate rights for those targeted  by surveillance but codify the rights of those doing the spying.

An article in the Intercept describes the redefining of "mass surveillance" as "bulk collection" as follows:

"This re-definition game goes as follows: yes, we vacuum up and store literally as much of the internet as we possibly can. Then we analyze all the data about what you’re doing, with whom you’re speaking, and who your network of associates is. Based on that analysis of all of you and your activities, we then read the communications that we want (with virtually no checks and concealing from you what percentage of it we’re reading), and store as much of the rest of it as technology permits for future trolling. But don’t worry: we’re only reading the Bad People’s emails. So run along then: no mass surveillance here. Just bulk collection! It’s not mass surveillance, but “enhanced collection techniques.” "

A 2000 European Court of Human Rights decision found that Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights was violated by such data collection even if data collected is not reviewed or exploited in any way. The defense had argued that no privacy violation happens if the data is not reviewed or exploited. Another ruling in 2000 was that even storing records of a person's activity in public such as attending demonstrations could be a violation of privacy since  “public information can fall within the scope of private life where it is systematically collected and stored in files held by the authorities.”

Another editorial in the Guardian explains that spying can play the part of the guard role that will protect a system that benefits most elites. Information gathered with the supposed purpose of keeping us safe from terrorists will be used to keep opposition forces from threatening "national security" the security of the elites that benefit most from the system.

Sources:
https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/03/13/orwellian-re-branding-mass-surveillance-merely-bulk-collection/
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/nhs-sell-out-tories-sign-largest-5323402
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes
http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/mar/10/nsa-gchq-technology-create-social-mobility-spy-on-citizens
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/mar/12/guardian-view-on-surveillance-parliament-slumbering-scrutineer?CMP=share_btn_tw
2 Comments
B. McPherson
15/3/2015 05:27:46 pm

These data rats burrowing into our lives with the ephemeral promise of granting us serenity and peace make me .... oops I might say something that may or may not or be likely to have other, less stable people do something that may or may not lead to civil disobedience which may or may not....

Reply
Dava Castillo
16/3/2015 04:54:43 pm

Thanks for the report Ken.

Alas, the balance between adequate security (spying) and protection of civil rights is going to an ongoing conversation in a free society. I know we need intelligence gathering, and with the sophistication of technology nowadays, one would think the gathers could sift out personal data--but then "those persons" could double agents or ISIL or any of the other terrorists folk.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    You can also find Ken at Ken Think Blogspot

    RSS Feed

    Like this writer's work please donate:
    Picture

    Ken Hanly

    Ken is a retired philosophy professor living in the boondocks of Manitoba, Canada, with his Filipina wife. He enjoys reading the news and writing articles. Politically Ken is on the far left of the political spectrum on many issues.

    Archives

    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015

    Categories

    All
    Aaron Driver
    Abdul El Sisi
    Abdul El-Sisi
    Abdullah Al Thinni
    Abdullah Al-thinni
    Aden
    Afghan Civil War
    Afghanistan
    Afghan Taliban
    Afghan War
    Ageela Salah
    Airport Security
    Alberta
    Alberta Election
    Alberta NDP
    Al Bunyan Al Marsoos
    Al-Bunyan Al-Marsoos
    Alexis Tsipras
    Ali Saleh
    Al-Khalis Prison
    Al-Mahdi A|-Barghathi
    Al Nusra Front
    Alondra Nunez
    Al Qaeda
    Al-Shabaab
    Al Wefaq
    Al-Wefaq
    Amnesty International
    Andal Ampatuan Sr
    Andalusia
    Angela Merkel
    Ansar Beit Al-Maqdis
    Anti-terror Legislation
    AQAM
    AQAP
    Assad
    Australian Election
    Bahrain
    BAM Forces
    Barach Obama
    Barack Obama
    Bashar Al-Assad
    Bayda
    Bees
    Bernie Sanders
    Bill-c51
    Boris Johnson
    British-navy
    Canada
    Canada In Iraq
    Canadian Bar Association
    Canadian Special Forces
    Cats
    CATSA
    Chemical Weapons Precursors
    China
    Christine Lagarde
    Civilian Casualties In Afghanistan
    Commodity Prices
    Cost Of Conflict
    Danger Of Neonictinoids
    Death Penalty
    Derna
    Dmitris Mardas
    Dorotea Garcia
    Drones
    Drone Strike Guidance
    Education
    Edward Snowden
    Egypt
    Elections
    Elena Panaritis
    El Sisi
    El-Sisi
    Enbridge
    Environmental Matters
    EU
    Eurogroup
    European Central Bank
    European Commission
    European Union
    Eurozone
    Euro Zone Greece
    Faiez Serraj
    Federica Mogherini
    Fethullah Gulen
    Fish Parasites
    Five Eyes
    Flogging
    Food Banks In Canada
    FSA
    Gadaffi
    Gang Rape
    Gary Johnson
    General John Nicholson
    General Martin Dempsey
    General Qassem Suleimani
    George Stathakis
    Georgia
    German War Reparations
    Germany Holds Journalist
    Ghat
    GHCQ
    Global Economies
    Global Economiic Growth
    Global Peace Index
    GNA
    Government Of National Accord
    Greece
    Greek Austerity
    Greek Bailout
    Greek Debt
    Greek Debt Crisis
    Greek Government
    Greek Referendum
    Green Energy Canada
    Green Party
    Gulf Cooperation Council
    Haider Al-Abadi
    Hail
    Health
    Helmand Province
    Hezbollah
    Hillary Clinton
    Hosni Mubarak
    House Of Representatives
    Houthi Rebels
    Houthis
    Hugh Heffner
    Hyon Chol
    Ibrahim Al-Rubaish
    Iceland
    IMF
    Iraq
    Iraqi Kurdistan
    Islamic State
    Islamic State In Libya
    Islamic State In Syria
    Israel
    Jabar Al-Luaibi
    James Clapper
    Jean-claude Juncker
    Jeremy Corbyn
    Jill Stein
    Jim Prentice
    Joachim Gauk
    John Kerry
    Jordan
    Jordan US Relations
    Journalism Is Not A Crime
    Justice And Development Party
    Key Pipeline
    Khalifa Haftar
    Kim Jong Un
    Kim Jong-un
    King Faisal Air Base
    King Mohammed VI
    King Salman
    Labor-participation-figures
    Lashkar Gah
    Lebanon
    Libertarian Candidate For President
    Libraries
    Libya
    Libya-dawn
    Libya Government Of National Accord
    Libya Kidnaps
    Libyan Banknotes
    Libyan Central Bank
    Libyan Government Of National Accord
    Libyan National Army
    Libya-peace-talks
    Libya-peace-talks
    Libyas Oil Ports
    Maguindanao Massacre
    Mansour Hadi
    Mariano Rajoy
    Martin Kobler
    Mass Surveillance
    Matteo Renzi
    Mexico
    Michel Aoun
    Migrant Crisis
    Misrata
    Misrata Militia
    Misrepresentation
    Misrrata Militia
    Mistaken Identity
    Mogadishu
    Mohammed Morsi
    Mokhtar Belmokhtar
    Mongolia
    Mongolian People's Party
    Montana
    Morocco Elections
    Muhammadu Buhari
    Mukalla
    NATO
    Nigeria
    Nigerian Oil Producition
    Nikos Voutis
    Noam Chomsky
    North Korea
    North Korea Russia Relations
    Nova Scotia
    NSA Spying
    Obama
    Oil Pipelines
    Omar Al-Hassan
    OPCW
    Operation Impact
    Operation Sophia
    Pakistan
    Palestine
    Park Geun-Hye
    Peace Talks With Taliban
    Pedro Sanchez
    Petroleum Facilities Guard
    Philippines
    Playboy Mansion
    Podemos
    Politics
    Pope Francis
    Poroshenko
    President Benigno Aquino III
    President El-Sisi
    President Hadi
    Price Of Oil
    Rachel Notley
    Ralf Badawi
    Ralph Goodale
    Raqqa
    Recep Erdogan
    Reiki
    Renewable Energy
    Right Sector
    Rival Banknotes Libya
    Russia
    Russian Elections
    Saad Hariri
    Salim Alaradi
    Saskatchewan
    Saudi Airstrikes
    Saudi Arabia
    SDF
    Sheikh Isa Qassim
    Shia Militia
    Shiites
    Sinai
    Sirte
    Sirte Offensive
    Solid Structure
    Somalia
    Somalia Attack
    Southern Manitoba
    South Korea
    South Ossetia
    Spain
    Spanish Politics
    Spoon Bending
    Stephen Biddle
    Stephen Harper
    Straits Of Mackinac
    Sunni
    Syria
    Syrian Civil War
    Syrian Democratic Forces
    Syrian Kurds
    Syriza
    Taliban Spring Offensive
    Tarin Kot
    Terrorism
    Texas
    Tikrit
    Tim Farron
    Tobruk Government
    Tornado
    Torture In UAE
    Trade Union Act
    Tripoli Government
    Troika
    Turkey
    Turkey In Syria
    UAE
    UK Labor
    Ukraine
    Ukrainian Security Forces
    UN
    UN In Yemen
    United Russia
    University Of Alberta
    UNSMIL
    Uruzgan
    US Drone Strikes
    US In Afghanistan
    US In Libya
    US In Syria
    US Politics
    US Presidential Election
    US Special Forces
    Vatican
    Vladimir Putin
    Wild Rose Party
    Wolfgang Schaeuble
    World Bank
    Xi Jinping
    Yanis Varoufakis
    Yellowstone River
    Yemen
    Yemen Ceasefire
    Yemen Peace Talks
    YPG

Click to set custom HTML
Support NEWTEK - Like what we do here at NEWTEK? If so, you should consider supporting us…
Running a news based website is fun, time consuming and can be costly. If you would like to help the site keep afloat please use the donate button
​
Sections:
News:
Welcome
Front page
Specials:

One Woman So Many Blogs


The Jeremy Corbyn Effect
​
NEWTEKWORLDNEWS:
About Us
Contact Us
Terms of Service
Cookie policy
Picture
  • Welcome
  • Latest
  • Animal Welfare
  • Barbara McPherson
  • Robert Weller
  • Dava Castillo
  • Odd News
  • Environment, science and health matters
  • On this day in History
  • About Us
  • Terms of Service
  • Our Cookie Policy
  • Welcome
  • Latest
  • Animal Welfare
  • Barbara McPherson
  • Robert Weller
  • Dava Castillo
  • Odd News
  • Environment, science and health matters
  • On this day in History
  • About Us
  • Terms of Service
  • Our Cookie Policy